| Year | League | Division | Wins | Losses | Ties | PCT. | Finish | AVG. | ERA | Manager | Ballpark |
| 1872 | NA | 5 | 19 | 0 | .208 | 8 | .271 | 5.55 | John Clapp | Mansfield Club Grounds |
Middletown Mansfields Team Index
- Played As: Middletown Mansfields (1872)
- Playoff Appearances: 0
- League Pennants: 0
- World Titles: 0